The Reality About Temu: Complaints and Considerations

The most downloaded free app in each the App Retailer and Google Play for a big a part of the final two months there was no TikTok, YouTube or Instagram, however a buying program that didn’t exist simply 4 months in the past.

Temu provides nice reductions on a bunch of merchandise, principally shipped instantly from Chinese language factories or warehouses. Along with extremely low costs, Temu can positively attribute its recognition to its technique of giving free stuff to customers who promote the app on their social networks and get family and friends to enroll.

However the firm—the U.S. department of Chinese language e-commerce large Pinduoduo—can be beginning to develop a fame for undelivered packages, mysterious fees, incorrect orders and unresponsive customer support. Temu has already been subjected to greater than 30 complaints to the Higher Enterprise Bureauand has a BBB buyer ranking of lower than 1.5 stars.

“They make supply guarantees, and other people do not get their stuff once they’re imagined to,” Melanie McGovern, the director of public relations and social media for the BBB, tells TIME.

When contacted by TIME, the corporate didn’t instantly deal with questions on buyer complaints or the BBB’s issues.

Temu’s enterprise mannequin—if it catches on—might even have main implications for American retailers and the worldwide provide chain within the coming yr.

What’s Temu and the way does it work?

At first look, Temu would possibly depart some customers questioning whether or not it is legit. Along with actually low cost shopper items, Temu boasts alternatives to earn credit by spinning video games or should you persuade your mates to hitch. Over the previous two months, posts praising Temu have unfold like wildfire throughout Fb, Twitter, and TikTok—although a lot of them use glowing language that appears to be recycled from one publish to the subsequent.

However, for now, Temu is a really actual platform, providing quite a lot of actual, deeply discounted merchandise, from air fryers to wi-fi Lenovo headphones ($8.98), laptop keyboards ($15) to garments ($1.69 for 5 pairs of socks) ). Customers who turned to Temu this month as a lifeline for vacation buying versus the best inflation in a technology made it one of many quickest rising platforms within the US

What does Temu promote?

The higher query is what to Worry doesn’t to promote Customers on Temu’s web site or app are instantly besieged by all types of offers: trainers for $17.48, common keys for $4.48, speaking toy hamsters for $6.99. Banner boasts objects as much as 90% off, due to a New Yr sale. The breadth of things and costs is outstanding, and the positioning’s aesthetic comes throughout as one thing like a digital greenback retailer.

Temu provides extraordinarily low costs on a variety of cheap shopper items shipped instantly from Chinese language factories and warehouses.

be afraid

However the technique is smart when you understand that Temu is a “sister firm” of the Chinese language e-commerce large Pinduoduo, which has supplied related offers in China for the previous few years. Pinduoduo has discovered success in China by promoting closely discounted merchandise instantly from producers to low-income patrons, in addition to agricultural merchandise to farmers. The corporate now has a market cap of $102 billionand its share value has risen throughout a yr wherein rivals reminiscent of Alibaba have taken extreme hits.

Pinduoduo launched Temu in September to courtroom the American market, and Temu’s web site lists an workplace in downtown Boston. A Temu spokesperson responded to TIME’s questions with a press release from its web site: that the corporate’s costs are made doable by “a deep community of sellers, logistics companions and [Pinduoduo’s] a longtime ecosystem constructed through the years.”

How do folks get stuff at no cost on Temu?

Whereas Temu’s costs are low cost, many new prospects do not truly pay something in any respect. That is as a result of Temu launched a social media marketing campaign wherein the extra you persuade others to enroll, the extra credit score you earn. This made it doable for some individuals who had earned sufficient credit score to obtain family items with out even giving Temu their bank card info.

“It appears to be like like they’re being sponsored to be a loss chief to get market share, which isn’t not like what Amazon has carried out for a very long time,” says Douglas Schmidt, a professor of laptop science at Vanderbilt College.

Brianna Lukey, who lives in Fort Value, Texas, says she obtained $200 value of stuff from Temu at no cost. She first heard about this system from a pal a month in the past, and initially dismissed it: “I do know there are a whole lot of issues that may not be legit,” she says. “However this was it.”

Lukey posted about Temu on Fb, TikTok and Snapchat, and ultimately satisfied pals to hitch this system, incomes a great deal of credit within the course of. She used them to order a hoop mild (priced at $25.48) for her plaster artwork small enterprise, Array of Aura’s, in addition to an oil diffuser ($5.48), a number of necklaces, and a mouse and keyboard for her daughter ($19.98). Lukey says the keyboard works properly: “I did not assume it could be such an important high quality. However it’s ok to be free,” she says. “So I am grateful for that.”

Temu might have given Lukey many objects with out her handing over any money, however the firm free promoting by Lukey’s social community in return. Temu manufacturers the marketing campaign as a approach for communities to come back collectively to economize: their slogan is “Staff Up, Worth Down.”

The technique appears to be working: When Lukey posted a photograph of her Temu cargo on Fb, her publish was quickly flooded with 70 feedback from her Fb pals, which principally consisted of individuals posting their very own referral hyperlinks in hopes of incomes related visitors.

What is the catch?

One of many feedback on Lukey’s publish, nevertheless, was considerably much less constructive than the remaining. Julie Roper Malloy wrote that the bundle she ordered from Temu, containing Christmas presents, by no means arrived, regardless of the corporate’s promise that it could be delivered no later than December 19. “Nonetheless ready on my order from November! Thanks Temu, you ruined Christmas!” she wrote.

In a sequence of Fb messages with TIME, Roper Malloy says she spent $178 on Temu presents for her household, together with two drones and a few make-up for her daughter. However the objects by no means arrived. Roper Malloy says she has contacted the corporate a number of occasions for a refund, which additionally has but to reach. “I’ll positively be extra diligent sooner or later after I order on-line,” she wrote. [Update: After this article’s publication, Roper Malloy received her Temu orders and a refund from the company.]

Roper Malloy shouldn’t be the one one to run into bother with Temu order. Temu itself admits that its orders take longer to reach than these from Amazon – normally 7-15 working days – as a result of they arrive from “abroad warehouses”. However plainly Temu additionally had issues delivering inside that bigger time window. In October, the Boston department of the Higher Enterprise Bureau opened a file on Temu and obtained 31 complaints in regards to the web site.

Temu at the moment has a C ranking on the BBB, and a mean buyer ranking of 1.4 stars out of 5, albeit from solely 20 opinions. (Complaints are separate from opinions, which don’t issue into the BBB’s official ranking.) McGovern on the BBB says it is uncommon for such a brand new firm to obtain so many complaints in such a brief time period. She notes that Temu has acknowledged and responded to each criticism posted to the BBB web site, however a lot of these complaints stay unresolved.

Temu’s sister firm, Pinduoduo, has lengthy accused of internet hosting gross sales of counterfeits, unlawful items or merchandise that don’t match their descriptions. (Pinduoduo wrote in its SEC filings that it instantly removes unauthorized merchandise or deceptive info on its platform, and freezes the accounts of sellers on the positioning who violate its insurance policies.)

There have been no BBB complaints alleging that the products Temu ships are faux or faux.

Moreover, in 2021, the deaths of two Pinduoduo staff spurred investigations and boycotts over the working situations of the corporate, in line with the New York occasions

How Temu might have an effect on the US economic system

Schmidt, at Vanderbilt who makes a speciality of safety and privateness, says Temu’s knowledge and privateness practices will not be out of the abnormal: The corporate collects a whole lot of private knowledge about customers after which disseminates that knowledge to promote advertisements. Nevertheless, he says the rise of Temu might have an even bigger affect not by way of privateness issues, however by way of strain on American firms and staff.

If increasingly more American shoppers flock to Temu to purchase discounted items, that might strain Amazon and different rivals to decrease their costs as properly, which might have an effect on wages, Schmidt argues.

“That is an fascinating instance of the manufacturing base in China turning into refined sufficient that it not feels prefer it must undergo distributors. They promote on to shoppers. And there are lots of people who’re struggling economically and on the lookout for a discount,” he says. This can clearly put strain on commodity producers to additional scale back their value base and revenue construction – which might have the consequence of additional eroding home manufacturing in the US.”

Correction, December 29

The unique model of the story misrepresented the connection between Temu and Pinduoduo. Pinduoduo shouldn’t be Temu’s dad or mum firm; each are subsidiaries of Pinduoduo Inc.

Extra Should Reads From TIME

Contact us at

Supply hyperlink

Leave a Comment